B"H
Cheshvan 5, 5766 * November 7, 2005
===============================
L E S S O N S I N T A N Y A
===============================
Today's Lesson:
Iggeret HaKodesh
(Middle of Epistle Twenty-Six)
------------------------------
Now, at first glance, what the words of this passage imply to those who lack understanding [10] is that the study of [the laws of] ritual prohibition and permission, and the Order of Taharot, [where the laws of purity and impurity are found], relates [only] to the Tree of [Knowledge of] Good and Evil.
Now this is most surprising in itself, [that a particular area within the Torah should be designated as the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, thus relating it to kelipat nogah, which is an admixture of good and evil]; moreover, this contradicts the plain meaning of Scripture and the teachings of our Sages, of blessed memory, that the entire Torah that has been revealed to us and to our children, [i.e., the dimension of nigleh], is called [11] "A tree of life to those who hold fast to it," [and not only the Book of the Zohar].
This is especially so, since [the Zohar] was [still] concealed in their days; indeed, the whole wisdom of the Kabbalah was hidden in their days and concealed from all the Torah scholars, except for a select few, and even then, [it was studied] in a concealed manner and not publicly, as stated in the Gemara. [12]
Thus R. Isaac Luria, of blessed memory, wrote [13] that it is only in these latter generations that "it is permitted and obligatory to reveal this wisdom" - [i.e., the Kabbalah, which illuminates the esoteric dimension of the Torah] - but not in the earlier generations.
[On this entire subject, see the introduction of R. Chayim Vital to Shaar HaHakdamot, which also appears as the first addendum to Kuntres Etz Chayim by the Rebbe Rashab (in the Kehot edition entitled Otzar HaChassidim), as well as the intro-duction of the Rebbe Rayatz to this Kuntres].
R. Shimon bar Yochai, too, stated in the sacred Zohar [14] that permission to reveal [the secrets of the Kabbalah] was only granted to himself and his associates.
Now this, too, is a remarkable wonder.
For if so, [i.e., according to a superficial reading of the above quotation from Ra'aya Mehemna, from which it would appear that only the Zohar is called the Tree of Life, while the revealed plane of the Torah is considered the Tree of Knowledge of Go od and Evil], then the study of [the laws of] ritual prohibition and permission, and surely [the study of] civil laws, such as litigation on monetary matters, [15] should not override the obligation of prayer, which is set out according to the secrets of the Zohar and on the Supernal Unions [of the various Divine Names and Supernal Sefirot], for those who are familiar with them, such as R. Shimon bar Yochai and his associates.
But this is not the case. [In fact, the study of the laws of what is ritually prohibited or permitted, and even the study of civil law, does override the obligation to pray at fixed times.]
As stated in the Gemara, [16] R. Shimon bar Yochai and his associates, and likewise any others whose Torah study is their sole occupation, do not interrupt [their Torah study] for prayer. [17]
[This applies] even when one is occupied with the study of civil law, like Rav Yehudah, all of whose studies were in the Order of Nezikin [18] [lit., "damages"]; nevertheless, [in order not to interrupt his studies], he prayed only every thirty days [19] when reviewing his studies, as stated in the Gemara. [30]
Also, in the Talmud Yerushalmi, in the first chapter of Berachot, [21] R. Shimon bar Yochai is of the opinion that even for the Reading of Shema one interrupts only the study of Scripture, but not of Mishnah, [the Oral Torah], the study of which is superior to the study of Scripture, [22] according to R. Shimon bar Yochai.
He did not differentiate between [studying] the Orders of Zera'im, Moed and Kodashim, and [studying] the Orders of Taharot and Nezikin. [23]
[He thus holds that even when studying the monetary laws in the Order of Nezikin one should not interrupt one's studies for the Reading of Shema.]
[24] (Actually, he [here] contradicts his own opinion, given in a number of instances in Ra'aya Mehemna, [25] that Mishnah [relative to Scripture] is termed a "handmaiden" [Heb.: shifchah], and so on; and Scripture, the Torah of Moses, is surely superior to the Kabbalah, which is termed a "queen" [Aram.: matrunita] in the above-quoted passage in Ra'aya Mehemna, while the Written Torah is termed a "king" [Aram.: malka.
Thus, according to the last-quoted set of terms from R. Shimon bar Yochai, Scripture is superior even to Kabbalah and surely to Mishnah. From the previous passage, however, as cited in the Talmud Yerushalmi, it would seem that he maintains that Mishnah is superior to Scripture, for one does not interrupt one's study of Mishnah in order to read Shema at its prescribed time, though one does interrupt one's study of Scripture.
Here the Alter Rebbe interpolates a Kabbalistic definition of the term malka "king":]
[24] (This is the Yesod of Abba vested in Z'eir Anpin, as stated by R. Isaac Luria, of blessed memory. [26] ))
[To resume the discussion of R. Shimon bar Yochai]:
Moreover, we find that R. Shimon bar Yochai dealt considerably [not only with the mere statements of law in the Mishnayot, but] also with the argumentation of problems and solutions, which [according to the original quotation from Ra'aya Mehemna] derive from the side of evil and from the spirit of impurity.
[This he did] even when he was in the cave, [where legal adjudication, especially in civil suits, was obviously uncalled for].
Indeed, the very fact that he underwent anguish [when forced to hide] in the cave made him worthy of these attainments.
For, as stated in the Gemara, [27] he countered every problematic query posed by R. Pinchas ben Yair with twenty-four solutions, and [R. Shimon] said to him: "If you had not seen me like this," [in this sorry state in the cave, ["you would not have found me like this"].
[24] (In fact, their principal occupation in the cave - [the principal occupation of Rashbi and his son, R. Eliezer] - must have been with the teachings of the Mishnayot, i.e., the six hundred Orders extant in those days [28] until the time of our holy Master, [R. Yehudah HaNasi, who compiled the Mishnayot in six Orders].
For he could have completed the Zohar and the Tikkunim, [the Tikkunei Zohar], in two or three months; for surely he did not repeat the same subject twice. [29])
[Surely, then, he was occupied almost the entire time with the study of the six hundred Orders of the Mishnah].
Moreover, our Sages, of blessed memory, have taught [30] that "Since the day the Temple was destroyed, the Holy One, blessed be He, has only the four cubits of Halachah." [The study of Torah law thus takes the place of the Holy Temple.
How, then, can we possibly say, as the above passage from Ra'aya Mehemna might superficially indicate, that the study of the laws of ritual permissibility, and the like, is designated as the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, and thus related to kelipat nogah, which is an admixture of good and evil]?
Footnotes:
10. Following early editions of the Tanya, the correct Hebrew
text here reads chaseirei (spelled with a resh), meaning
"those who lack." Other editions appear to read chassidei
(spelled with a daled), and have led to some mistranslation.
11. Mishlei 3:18.
12. Chagigah 11b; 13a.
13. See Shaar HaGilgulim, end of Introduction XV; et al.
14. Note of the Rebbe: "See beginning of Idra Rabbah
(Zohar III, 127b ff.) and many other places in the Zohar
where Rashbi expresses himself similarly."
15. Note of the Rebbe: "It could be suggested that civil
law is singled out, for in this field the law of the Torah
[sometimes] takes into account `the custom of local
merchants' or `the law of the land' or a waiver by one of
the parties to a transaction; and so on." [Hence the most
"remarkable wonder" would be that the study of such a
seemingly mundane level of law should override the seemingly
more spiritual occupation of prayer.]
16. Shabbat 11a.
17. Note of the Rebbe: "Many have asked: `If so, how were
the Supernal Unions (yichudim) usually effected by daily
prayer, accomplished [by them]?' For an answer, see Torah Or
38d, 69a, et al. [where it is explained that these holy
Sages were so self-effacing and so G-d-fearing that their
Torah study bore spiritual results which others can only
achieve through prayer]."
18. Berachot 20a.
19. See note 17, above.
20. Rosh HaShanah 35a.
21. End of Law 2.
22. Note of the Rebbe: "It could be suggested that the
Alter Rebbe adds the reason, since the reason too is part of
the question, as is soon stated. Note that Mishnah is the
revealed level of the Torah, while Scripture is related to
Kabbalah ( see the commentary in Likkutei Torah on the
maamar beginning Lo Tashbit). But see Hilchot Talmud Torah
of the Alter Rebbe, beginning of sec. 2, [from which it
would seem that Kabbalah is related to the Oral Torah, not
to Scripture]."
23. Note of the Rebbe: "The Alter Rebbe omits the Order
of Nashim, etc. (See Likkutei Levi Yitzchak on Tanya.)"
[Explaining this omission, the father of the Rebbe
states there that the Alter Rebbe's point could not be
proved from the fact that the study of Nashim (which deals
with marriage and divorce, etc.) overrides the Reading of
Shema. For, as the Gemara says regarding the erasing of the
Divine Name in the course of the purification of a sotah
(the woman suspected of adultery), G-d is even willing to
allow the Divine Name to be erased, so long as this will
restore peace between a husband and h is wife. It is thus to
be expected that the Reading of Shema, whose essence is the
affirmation of the unity of the Divine Name, should defer to
the study of this particular Order. Other Kabbalistic
reasons are offered there as well.]
24. These parentheses/brackets are in the original text.
25. Note of the Rebbe: "This requires further examination
and research [to find where Rashbi actually states this in
Ra'aya Mehemna]. See Zohar I, 27b (and in the Introduction
to Tikkunei Zohar XIV, foot of p. 71 ff.); also Biurei
HaZohar ther e [by the Mitteler Rebbe], (as well as by the
Tzemach Tzedek, Volume II)."
26. Shaar HaMitzvot, Parshat Vaetchanan; et al.
27. Shabbat 33b.
28. Chagigah 14a and Rashi there.
29. The author of Minchat Elazar poses the following question
(Divrei Torah 8:70): The study of the Mishnayot would
likewise not have taken more than several months, if
they did not debate all the legal problems and solutions
involved. We can thus say the same for their study of
the Zohar and Tikkunei Zohar: while several months would
suffice for the bare-bone text itself, even thirteen years
would not suffice for discussing and plumbing its depths!
The Rebbe answers this by noting that the Alter Rebbe
anticipated this question in this very letter.
He prefaces the fact that it took the compiler of the
Gemara, R. Ashi, a full ten years to study the first and
second editions of the Talmud which then comprised only six
Orders. R. Shimon, who was of far greater stature (see
Eruvin 54a) and studied the six hundred Orders of the
Mishnah in much greater depth, propounding twenty-four
solutions to every problem, surely was fully occupied in the
cave with the study of the Mishnah.
With regard to the Zohar and Tikkunei Zohar, however, since
the Alter Rebbe here quoted the Ra'aya Mehemna to the effect
that they contain "no problematic query, which emanates from
the side of evil, and no controversy, which emanates from
the spirit of impurity," there were then no questions nor
disputations. Surely, then, this took no more than several
months.
30. Berachot 8a.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
NEW COURSE FROM THE JEWISH LEARNING INSTITUTE:
"Beyond Never Again: The Holocaust - A View from the Soul"
"Explore the ways in which the Holocaust continues to affect our generation and colors what it means to live as a Jew today.
"The Holocaust forces us to grapple with the existence of evil and suffering. It challenges us to find faith and optimism in the face of devastation and despair. And it awes us as we encounter heroes of the spirit who fought for truth and decency in the darkest of times."
Register now, hundreds of locations in the US, and worldwide:
http://www.chabad.org/324215
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
© Copyright
Kehot Publication Society
770 Eastern Parkway / Brooklyn, New York 11213
(718) 774-4000 / FAX (718) 774-2718
http://www.kehotonline.com
Brought to you by Chabad.org
To listen to an audio version of today's lesson, please click one of the following links:
MP3: http://www.chabad.org/dailystudy/audio.asp?what=tanya&tDate=11/07/2005&format=m3u
Real: http://www.chabad.org/dailystudy/audio.asp?what=tanya&tDate=11/07/2005&format=rm
To view this lesson online with Hebrew text and formatting plus many features, please visit: http://www.chabad.org/dailystudy/tanya.asp
For more daily Torah study, please visit: http://www.chabad.org/dailystudy/
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
** Enjoyed this email? Please help us continue sharing the
study of Torah and Jewish traditions:
Dedicate or sponsor an email to mark your special occasion!
Please click here: http://www.chabad.org/dedications
Please click here to make a donation to Chabad.org:
http://www.chabad.org/donate
** To subscribe to more Chabad.org email lists please click here:
http://www.chabad.org/subscribe
** To be removed from this email list please click here:
http://www.chabad.org/unsub.asp?UserID=268334,13,261645,0,217
If you would just like your email suspended and resumed at a later
date, please let us know here:
http://www.chabad.org/go.asp?p=vacation_request&email=moshiachtv.maildrop@blogger.com
** You are subscribed as: moshiachtv.maildrop@blogger.com. If your e-mail address is changing
please send us your new email address here:
http://www.chabad.org/go.asp?p=address_change&email=moshiachtv.maildrop@blogger.com
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Chabad.org
Part of the Chabad Online Network
A division of Chabad Lubavitch Media Center
770 Eastern Parkway * Brooklyn, NY * 11213
Web: http://www.chabad.org
Feedback: http://www.chabad.org/tools/feedback.asp
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Comment on this story
Click here to print this Page
To remove yourself from the mailing list please 
