Thursday, November 03, 2005

ONCE UPON A CHASID: A Case Is Referred To Lubavitch (Noach)


Cheshvan 1, 5766 * November 3, 2005


Parshat Noach

And G-d descended to see the city and the tower which the sons of man had built (Genesis 11:5)

Obviously, G-d did not need to "come down" in order to see their crime; but He wished to teach all future judges that one must not judge the defendant until they see and appreciate...
- Rashi's commentary

Do not judge your fellow, unless you are in his place.
- Ethics of the Fathers, 2:2.

* * * *

A Case Is Referred To Lubavitch

In 1857, a fire destroyed much of the town of Lubavitch, including the synagogue and study hall of the then Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Mendel, and the homes of the Rebbe and his sons. Rabbi Menachem Mendel initiated a rebuilding campaign and a new and expanded 'courtyard' was constructed to serve as the headquarters of Chabad-Lubavitch chassidism.

At the groundbreaking of the new complex, a festive farbrengen was held. Long tables were set up in the courtyard to accommodate the large crowd of chassidim. When Rabbi Menachem Mendel joined them, he asked: "Do you wish to hear a discourse of chassidic teaching or a story?" The chassidim replied that they wished to hear a story.

"Reb Yaakov," began Rabbi Menachem Mendel, "was an impoverished tavern-keeper at a country crossroads and a chassid of the 'Holy Ruzhiner', Rabbi Israel of Ruzhin. He leased the tavern from another Jew, also named Reb Yaakov, who had a deal with the local nobleman: he would lease the nobleman's entire estate and, in turn, sublease the fields, the forests, the mill, the tavern, and other assets to other Jews.

"Business at the tavern was poor and Reb Yaakov the tavern-keeper failed to meet the rent that was due Reb Yaakov the lease-holder. Months went by, the debt accumulated, and still the tavern-keeper found himself unable to make even a token payment. Finally, the lease-holder lost his patience and threatened to evict his delinquent tenant.

"The distressed tavern-keeper travelled to his rebbe, the Holy Ruzhiner, and complained that his lease-holder, Reb Yaakov, was about to deprive him of his home and livelihood. The Ruzhiner summoned the lease-holder and asked him to forgive a destitute Jew his debt. Now this Reb Yaakov was an upright and compassionate man; he did as the Rebbe asked and more. Not only did him forgive the tavern-keeper his outstanding debt, he even reduced the monthly payments on the tavern. His only request was that the tavern-keeper promise that henceforth he would pay the rent on time.

"But business at the tavern continued to plummet and the poor man was simply unable to keep his promise. The benevolent Reb Yaakov allowed him one extension after another, until he again lost patience with his hapless tenant. When his repeated demands for payment yielded only excuses and more promises, he notified the tavern-keeper that if he could not come up with at least some of the money owed by the end of the month he is to remove himself from the premises.

"The poor tavern-keeper, without a kopeck in his pocket, again traveled to his rebbe and poured out his heart. Once more, the Ruzhiner appealed to Reb Yaakov, and again the latter fulfilled the Rebbe's request and forgave the loan. Sensitive to his tenant's difficulties, he even further reduced the sum to be paid each month.

"Still, the tavern-keeper's fortune only worsened. Again his debt accumulated, again the lease-holder pressed for payment, again he was served notice, again he rushed to Ruzhin. However this time the Ruzhner's appeals were to no avail. "The Rebbe is not the master over my money," maintained Reb Yaakov the lease-holder, "I have already done far more than anyone can reasonably expect of me. I can no longer afford to absorb these ever-mounting debts. Either he pays up or I lease the tavern to another." A short while later, the tavern-keeper was evicted from the building which housed his living quarters and his defunct establishment.

"Years later, Reb Yaakov the lease-holder passed away and his soul came to stand judgement before the heavenly court. Many were his virtues, as he had been a man of compassion and integrity. He had conducted his business affairs with honestly and sensitively and had contributed generously to the needy. But one nasty stain blemished his upright life: he had cast a fellow Jew out into the street, depriving him and his family of young children of their home and livelihood.

" 'What more could I have done?!' objected Reb Yaakov. 'I forgave him the money time and again and continuously reduced the rent. Besides, this court is not qualified to judge me on this matter.'

" 'Why do you say so?' asked the supernal judge.

" 'Here in heaven you have no idea what money is,' argued the defendant. 'You do not understand what it means to earn a livelihood, so you cannot condone the fact that I did what I did 'merely' because the man owed me money. I wish to be judged by a court that appreciates the value of money, that has experienced the struggle to provide for one's family.'

"The heavenly court conceded that Rabbi Yaakov had a point. So his case was referred to the souls of two great authorities on Jewish law, Rabbi Yosef Caro and Rabbi Yoel Sirkish. The two reviewed his case and found him guilty.

"Still Reb Yaakov protested. 'These great men have long forsaken the physical world and its petty cares. It is centuries since they have been obliged to worry about money. I demand that my case be reviewed by a human court, comprised of souls still enmeshed in bodies and bodily needs.' "

At this point, Rabbi Menachem Mendel addressed his chassidim: "Well, what do you say?" The assembled chassidim were at loss to reply.

Again Rabbi Menachem Mendel demanded: "I maintain that Reb Yaakov is in the right. What do you say? Eh?"

Finally, the crowd caught on that the 'case' was now being decided. Together with Rabbi Menachem Mendel they proclaimed: "Girecht! (He is in the right!) Girecht! Girecht!"



"Beyond Never Again: The Holocaust - A View from the Soul"

"Explore the ways in which the Holocaust continues to affect our generation and colors what it means to live as a Jew today.

"The Holocaust forces us to grapple with the existence of evil and suffering. It challenges us to find faith and optimism in the face of devastation and despair. And it awes us as we encounter heroes of the spirit who fought for truth and decency in the darkest of times."

Register now, hundreds of locations in the US, and worldwide:


© Copyright
Kehot Publication Society
770 Eastern Parkway / Brooklyn, New York 11213
(718) 774-4000 / FAX (718) 774-2718

Brought to you by

For more Parshah study, please visit:


** Enjoyed this email? Please help us continue sharing the
study of Torah and Jewish traditions:

Dedicate or sponsor an email to mark your special occasion!
Please click here:

Please click here to make a donation to

** To subscribe to more email lists please click here:

** To be removed from this email list please click here:,17,261645,0,217
If you would just like your email suspended and resumed at a later
date, please let us know here:

** You are subscribed as: If your e-mail address is changing
please send us your new email address here:

Part of the Chabad Online Network

A division of Chabad Lubavitch Media Center
770 Eastern Parkway * Brooklyn, NY * 11213


No comments:

Related Posts with Thumbnails